| Champion | Defenses | Reign Length | Event Won |
|---|
| Champion | Defenses | Reign Length | Event Won |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shotzi | 1 | - days | NXT Halloween Havoc IV |
| Athena | 7 | 189 days | NXT Stand & Deliver III |
| Ivy Nile | 3 | 56 days | NXT RoadBlock III |
| Jakara Jackson | 4 | 84 days | NXT Vengeance Day III |
| Blake Monroe | 5 | 105 days | NXT HeatWave III |
| Jamie Hayter | 2 | 21 days | NXT GoldRush III |
| Paige | 6 | 147 days | NXT New Years Evil II |
| Nikkita Lyons | 2 | 35 days | NXT DeadLine II |
| Blake Monroe | 2 | 28 days | NXT Vengeance Day II |
| Jacy Jayne | 4 | 63 days | NXT Great American Bash II |
| Vacant | 0 | 1 Hour | NXT Great American Bash II |
| Mercedes Mone | 3 | 91 days | NXT BattleGround II |
| Stephanie Vaquer | 5 | 119 days | NXT New Years Evil I |
| Roxanne Perez | 9 | 217 days | NXT BattleGround I |