| # | Champion | Title Defenses | Event Won | Reign Length |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Roxanne Perez | 9 | NXT BattleGround I | 217 Days |
| 1 | Stephanie Vaquer | 5 | NXT New Years Evil I | 119 Days |
| 1 | Mercedes Mone | 3 | NXT BattleGround II | 91 Days |
| 1 | Vacated | 0 | NXT Great American Bash II | 1 Hour |
| 1 | Jacy Jayne | 4 | NXT Great American Bash II | 63 Days |
| 1 | Blake Monroe | 2 | NXT Vengeance Day II | 28 Days |
| 1 | Nikkita Lyons | 2 | NXT DeadLine II | 35 Days |
| 1 | Paige | 1 | NXT New Years Evil II | - Days |